The effect of focused written corrective feedback and. Second language acquisition and corrective feedback. Exploring student engagement with written corrective feedback in firstyear. Index terms feedback, metalinguistic feedback, task, accuracy i. Seventyeight learners from two large us universities participated in the study. Differential effects of oral and written corrective. Metalinguistic feedback a dissertation submitted to the faculty of the graduate school of arts and sciences of georgetown university in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of doctor of philosophy in linguistics by jaemyung goo, m. The findings of her earlier study suggested that the learners with higher levels of analytic ability benefited more from direct corrective feedback without metalinguistic corrective feedback than the learners with low metalinguistic ability. This article examines whether there is any difference between the effect of oral and written corrective feedback cf on learners accurate use of english articles. Corrective feedback and wmc 447 learning as well as the relative effects of recasts and metalinguistic feedback on l2 development i. The comparative effect of direct written corrective. The effect of two forms of computerautomated metalinguistic corrective feedback jianwu gao, capital normal university shuang ma, capital normal university abstract this study investigated whether the effect of two forms of computerautomated metalinguistic corrective feedback in drills transferred to subsequent writing tasks. Metalinguistic awareness and nonalphabetic literacy by analogy with the role of phonemic awareness in alphabetic literacy, it might be expected that awareness of syllables would be crucial to learning to read in a syllabary a writing system in which there is a unique symbol for. This study examines the differential effect of two types of written corrective feedback cf and the extent to which language analytic ability mediates the effects of cf on the acquisition of articles by adult intermediate esl learners of various l1 backgrounds n 91.
Therefore, even though many empirical studies deal with the effectiveness of corrective feedback andor the relative effectiveness of implicit and explicit corrective feedback, we still. The effect of written corrective feedback on efl students. It then reports on a new study of the effects of these two types of corrective feedback on the acquisition of past tenseed. The effect of metalinguistic corrective feedback on efl. Metalinguistics is the branch of linguistics that studies language and its relationship to other cultural behaviors. The effects of direct corrective feedback and metalinguistic explanation on efl learners implicit and explicit knowledge of english definite and indefinite articles article 6, volume 7, issue 16, summer and autumn 2015, page 1146 pdf 709. Effects of recasts and metalinguistic corrective feedback on the acquisition of implicit and explicit l2 knowledge. A comparative study mojtaba mohammadi islamic azad university, roudehen branch, tehraniran corrective feedback has long been raised in education and psychology, but has attracted much attention in recent years, especially with the advent of formfocused instruction. In the current study, we present the results of an experiment with 30 persian efl learners in which we explored the learners perceptions of recasts and metalinguistic corrective feedback. Investigating the effects of three types of corrective feedback on.
Furthermore, the effect of direct focused and unfocused written corrective feedback on the iranian efl learners. The effect of six different corrective feedback strategies on iranian english language learners ielts writing task 2 reza vahdani sanavi1 and majid nemati1 abstract scholars have long studied the effect of corrective feedback strategies on the writing ability of language learners, but few. Effect of metalinguistic teacher corrective feedback on. The most comprehensive study in this regard is the metaanalysis by brown 2014.
In an experimental design two experimental groups and a con. Adults have advanced to the stage of formal operations which enables them to. To this end, the current research presents the results of a quasiexperimental study with a pretest, immediateposttest, delayedposttest design, using 12 intact intermediate englishasasecondlanguage classes with adult learners. The study thus classifies l2 teachers in two broad categories. Metalinguistic knowledge and corrective feedback 8 liu, q. Clearly indicating that the students utterance was incorrect, the teacher provides the correct form. Despite the plethora number of studies conducted to investigate the effectiveness of metalinguistic cf on the written work of the learners e. The effectiveness of corrective feedback for the acquisition of l2 grammar. Without providing the correct form, the teacher poses questions or provides comments or information related to the formation of the students utterance for example, do we say it like that. Introduction as a matter of fact second language acquisition has been tied to the. A, department of teaching english as a foreign language supervisor.
Pdf corrective feedback has long been raised in education and psychology but has attracted much attention in recent years, especially with. Mey in his book, trends in linguistics, describes mikhail bakhtins. An investigation of metalinguistic corrective feedback in. Recast and metalinguistic feedback in teaching and. Corrective feedback is one of the issues in second language learning which has grown to be a major concern both among theoreticians and practitioners. Methodological synthesis of research on the effectiveness of corrective feedback in l2 writing. As its name refers, corrective feedback is used to give. According to ellis 2012, teachers are faced with numerous challenges when choosing corrective feedback methods. Issues of corrective feedback in second language acquisition. Recast and metalinguistic feedback in teaching and learning l2 writing.
Index termsfeedback, metalinguistic feedback, task, accuracy i. Jodee walters july 2010 this study was designed to investigate student and teacher perception of. High communication abilities are required in order to teach and motivate these students effectively. The effect of metalinguistic corrective feedback on efl learners grammatical accuracy in everyday classrooms, teachers and their students must interact with each other on many levels. As its name refers, corrective feedback is used to give information on correctness of learners utterances and provide them with the correct. This article will draw on research in second language acquisition sla and language pedagogy in order to examine a number of controversial issues relating to one type of feedbackcorrective feedback. The participants were divided into two proficiency levels based on their performance on a standardized proficiency test. Effects of recasts and metalinguistic corrective feedback. Swain also attributes considerable importance to corrective feedback, in. Background the term corrective feedback has recently been imperative part of the foreign language teaching.
A comparative study article pdf available in journal of asia tefl 63. Students in the recast treatment condition also obtained higher significant mean scores than those who received metalinguistic corrective feedback. Types of corrective feedback center for advanced research on. Metalinguistic knowledge kim major reference works. Article the effect of two forms of computerautomated metalinguistic corrective feedback authors. Effects of metalinguistic feedback on grammatical accuracy of.
The effect of two forms of computerautomated metalinguistic. Approved april 2015 by the graduate supervisory committee. The effect of two forms of computerautomated metalinguistic corrective feedback. The effect of six different corrective feedback strategies.
Research on corrective feedback little research has investigated the proportions of cf andor the targets of cf. Teachers and students perceptions of different types of corrective feedback in writing najmaddin, shler m. Effect of metalinguistic teacher corrective feedback on writing. L2 teachers explicit and implicit corrective feedback and. Corrective feedback cf refers to teacher and peer responses to learners erroneous second language l2 production. The effect of metalinguistic corrective feedback on. Corrective feedback in primary efl classrooms in turkey1. Metalinguistic knowledge refers to the explicit and declarative knowledge that learners have regarding language which plays a critical role in second language acquisition sla. By inspecting both teacher handbooks, like ur 1996 and published empirical studies chandler, 2003. Corrective feedback and teacher development escholarship. Previous research has examined issues regarding metalinguistic knowledge in areas such as instructed sla, teacher education, l2 learner individual differences, and l2.
To achieve the purposes of this study, the following research question was posed. An investigation of metalinguistic corrective feedback in writing. Moreover, the highaptitude learners who had revived metalinguistic. Great many studies have been conducted to investigate the efficacy of the. The effect of spatial intelligencebased metalinguistic. The efficacy of metalinguistic corrective feedback cf has drawn growing. Guenette 2007 similarly indicates studies systematically scrutinizing corrective feedback have been quite insufficient. Using peer computermediated corrective feedback to. Technology and written corrective feedback with the advances in technology, the feedback practices have also experienced changes as some teachers are considering to move on to electronic feedback. Metalinguistic feedback, in contrast to recasts, is an explicit type of corrective feedback as it provides comments, information, or questions related to the well. On the differential effects of computermediated and. The recent burgeoning of research into oral cf is attributable to its pedagogical and theoretical significance. A metalinguistic negotiation is a metalinguistic dispute that concerns a normative issue about what a word should mean, or, similarly, about how it should be used, rather than the descriptive issue about what it does mean.
Chandler 2003 metalinguistic corrective feedback operates as the provision of the correct form in the students written texts by underlining the error and writing. According to lyster and ranta 1997 there are different kinds of feedback. The effects of direct corrective feedback and metalinguistic 117 examine whether written cf can develop explicit, implicit, or both knowledge types. What is the frequency of each type of corrective feedback used by the teacher in teaching speaking in ums.
The second type of metalinguistic corrective feedback consists of providing. Oral corrective feedback elt journal oxford academic. The term corrective feedback has recently been imperative part of the foreign language teaching. Exploring student engagement with written corrective. The relationship between metalinguistic knowledge, error. Metalinguistic awareness and literacy acquisition in. This type of corrective feedback is usually referred to as metalinguistic feedback. Which concepts should we use metalinguistic negotiations.
Thats not how you say it in french, and is it feminine. Corrective feedback has long been raised in education and psychology, but has attracted much attention in recent years, especially with the advent of formfocused instruction. University of texas at austin center for open educational resources and language learning doi. I argue that the same evidence that supports thinking that certain ordinary disputes are metalinguistic negotiations also. The comparative effect of direct written corrective feedback and metalinguistic explanation on learne rs explicit and implicit knowledge of the english indefinite article author links open overlay panel natsuko shintani a rod ellis b. Pdf recast and metalinguistic feedback in teaching and. Journal of english language teaching and learning no. Corrective feedback in classrooms at different proficiency. Outputprompting metalinguistic feedback elicitation request for clarification repetition 2.
769 833 1071 1347 1333 1182 881 416 1128 1026 516 754 1144 963 283 1009 1274 1234 133 1244 368 1457 1207 1354 1253 974 406 482 994 483 141